You can download the Greater London Authority (GLA) report, 'The Search for Common Ground" can now be downloaded by clicking here.
My research and writing can be found in chapter 2 of the report. I want to make sure that everyone is aware of my contribution as there have been 'political' problems with some parts of the report. The key findings of my chapter are shown below (reproduced from the Executive Summary):
Chapter 2: A normal week?
To explore the context and implications of representations of Islam and Muslims in the media, a study was made of the British press over the course of a week. The week beginning Monday 8 May 2006 was chosen at random about a month in advance. A count was made of every article mentioning ‘Islam’, ‘Muslims’, derivatives such as ‘Islamic’ and ‘Islamist’, and words and phrases with an obvious association with Islam, for example ‘Sunni’ and ‘Shi’a’.
On the basis of these criteria, 352 articles were identified. They were categorised according to type of paper, whether they were about domestic or international affairs, whether the context was negative, positive or neutral, and whether the articles expressed a sense of threat or crisis. The principal findings included:
• There were substantial differences between daily newspapers with regard to how many articles mentioning Islam or Muslims they contained during the week in question. There were just over 50 articles in the Guardian, over 40 in The Times, Financial Times, Daily Telegraph and Independent, but less than 20 in the Sun, Mirror, Express and Star.
• Tabloids and broadsheets differed not only in the amount of coverage they provided but also in whether they focused on domestic or international affairs. Close to 60 per cent of articles in tabloids pertained to Britain and 40 per cent to the wider world. In the case of the broadsheets, however, the proportions were the other way round: 60 per cent were about the wider world, and 40 per cent about Britain.
• Of the 352 articles that referred to Islam and Muslims during the week in question, 91 per cent were judged to be negative in their associations. Only four per cent were judged to be positive, and five per cent were judged neutral.
• In 12 of the 19 papers studied during the week there were no positive associations.
• In the tabloids, 96 per cent of all articles were judged to be negative, compared with 89 per cent in the broadsheets. It is relevant to bear in mind in this connection that the combined circulation of the The search for common ground Muslims, non-Muslims and the UK media xvii tabloids is about three times greater than that of the broadsheets (May 2007 figures).
• It was judged that almost half of the articles represented Islam as a threat. Of these, about a third pertained to Britain and two-thirds to the wider world.
• The overall picture presented in the media during the week in question was that on the world stage Islam is profoundly different from, and a serious threat to, the West; and that, within Britain, Muslims are different from – and a threat to – ‘us’.
Showing posts with label equalities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label equalities. Show all posts
Wednesday, 14 November 2007
Monday, 22 October 2007
The 'first' decade of Islamophobia: 10 years of the Runnymede Trust report "Islamophobia: a challenge for us all"
This week marks the tenth anniversary of the publication of the Runnymede Trust/ Commission on British Muslims and Islamophobia report, "Islamophobia: a challenge for us all". Without any doubt whatsoever, the report has been one of the most influential documents of its kind.
In recognition of this, I have put together a short document that includes a new 'think-piece' about Islamophobia that you might be interested in reading. You can download this for free by visiting my website at:
www.chris-allen.co.uk
I would be really interested to see what you all have to say so add your comments/ thoughts/ criticisms below. Any that are sent to me via e-mail will also be added...
Chris
In recognition of this, I have put together a short document that includes a new 'think-piece' about Islamophobia that you might be interested in reading. You can download this for free by visiting my website at:
www.chris-allen.co.uk
I would be really interested to see what you all have to say so add your comments/ thoughts/ criticisms below. Any that are sent to me via e-mail will also be added...
Chris
Labels:
equalities,
Government policy,
Islamophobia,
multiculturalism,
Muslims,
racism
Friday, 19 October 2007
BRAP 'DNA' - Does Not Accept - Watson's Racist Ranting
A BRAP release distributed yesterday in response to Dr James Watson's racist outpourings:
"BRAP refute some of the ideas voiced by the American DNA pioneer Dr James Watson. In Britain to promote his new book, Dr Watson - who won a Nobel Prize in 1962 for his part in discovering the structure of DNA – has claimed that black people are less intelligent than white people, that he was "inherently gloomy about the prospect of Africa" because "all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours - whereas all the testing says not really". He also suggests that a woman should have the right to abort her unborn child if tests could determine it would be homosexual. He added that whilst he hoped everyone was equal, "people who have to deal with black employees find this is not true".
BRAP have argued in our briefing paper, “The social construction of race” (available to download free from www.brap.org.uk) that there are as many theories to inform the perspective that ‘race’ is a social construct - a view that is backed up by a wealth of recent social and scientific research - as indeed there are those that suggest it is biological.
Perpetuating these ideas under the guise or legitimacy of pseudo-science is extremely dangerous as indeed history has sought to prove. In doing so, Dr Watson is not only fanning the flames of controversy – possibly to generate interest in his new book – but is contributing to the persistence of a discredited and deeply divisive concept. It is a shame that such an eminent individual should allow his own irrational prejudices to overshadow such an acclaimed and distinguished scientific record. It will be even more of a shame if some seek to use this same scientific record to legitimise the notion that ‘race’ is a biological reality.
BRAP is committed to challenging and responding to both our own and to other people’s thinking around equalities and human rights. We see it as a crucial mechanism through which we question our past and current approach to tackling the causes and effects of racism and all other forms of discrimination in today’s society."
"BRAP refute some of the ideas voiced by the American DNA pioneer Dr James Watson. In Britain to promote his new book, Dr Watson - who won a Nobel Prize in 1962 for his part in discovering the structure of DNA – has claimed that black people are less intelligent than white people, that he was "inherently gloomy about the prospect of Africa" because "all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours - whereas all the testing says not really". He also suggests that a woman should have the right to abort her unborn child if tests could determine it would be homosexual. He added that whilst he hoped everyone was equal, "people who have to deal with black employees find this is not true".
BRAP have argued in our briefing paper, “The social construction of race” (available to download free from www.brap.org.uk) that there are as many theories to inform the perspective that ‘race’ is a social construct - a view that is backed up by a wealth of recent social and scientific research - as indeed there are those that suggest it is biological.
Perpetuating these ideas under the guise or legitimacy of pseudo-science is extremely dangerous as indeed history has sought to prove. In doing so, Dr Watson is not only fanning the flames of controversy – possibly to generate interest in his new book – but is contributing to the persistence of a discredited and deeply divisive concept. It is a shame that such an eminent individual should allow his own irrational prejudices to overshadow such an acclaimed and distinguished scientific record. It will be even more of a shame if some seek to use this same scientific record to legitimise the notion that ‘race’ is a biological reality.
BRAP is committed to challenging and responding to both our own and to other people’s thinking around equalities and human rights. We see it as a crucial mechanism through which we question our past and current approach to tackling the causes and effects of racism and all other forms of discrimination in today’s society."
Labels:
equalities,
human rights,
racism
Friday, 21 September 2007
A Message to the CEHR
The 1st October sees the launch of the new Commission on Equalities and Human Rights (CEHR). This new body will bring together the work of the now defunct Commission for Racial Equality (CRE), Disability Rights Commission (DRC) and the Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC) to champion the cause to reduce inequality, eliminate discrimination, strengthen good relations between people and protect human rights. Bringing together, for the first time, all of the various equalities strands – race, disability, gender, age, religion and belief, and sexual orientation – it will seek to take an active role in helping to achieve change to benefit some of the most vulnerable and least well represented people in our society.
Although we are optimistic about the potential for the new Commission to provide our country with opportunities to refresh our thinking and practice on issues of equality, there is evidence that the inequalities gap is widening and we fear that a unique opportunity to make a real difference will be lost. If it is, then so too will the chance to conscientiously address the discrimination and inequality that affect the everyday lives and experiences of those many British people that exist at the sharp end of society. Because of this, discrimination and inequality thus blights all our lives.
To ensure we do not lose this opportunity, we need to move away from the recent preoccupation with ‘identity’ and ‘single’ identity politics: a point made in the Commission on Integration & Cohesion report, Shared futures. The constant focus on ‘Muslims’, for example, has meant that the ‘problem’ of extremism has become something that is seen to be about ‘them’ rather than ‘us’. Not only does this hinder the need for society as a whole to take a shared responsibility for equalities issues, but it also creates misunderstandings and barriers between us. As regards extremism in particular, this preoccupation with identity also obscures, rather than illuminates: acts of terrorism are criminal acts, committed by individuals, quite irrespective of the ideology they allege to purport. For the CEHR, continuing to focus on identity rather than inequality will be both incongruent and counter-productive, weakening rather than strengthening the kind of social cohesion most of us – including the Government - want to see: one where who I am will make me more disadvantaged than who you are.
Transitions are never easy. The CEHR should lead the way, pre-empting the typical knee-jerk responses by identifying the commonalities that exist between us: our commonalities as human beings first and foremost. To be successful, it must address the ‘issues’: those current barriers that prevent all of us from being treated equally. These are not necessarily going to be the same ‘issues’ as before, so letting go of the past will be a major hurdle.
With the establishment of the CEHR, we look forward to the challenges ahead and the opportunity to work together to extend and strengthen our shared understanding of what it is to be a citizen of Britain in the 21st century. To do this, we must not allow the crucial debates to be lost: the stakes are too high and the potential rewards too great.
(This entry will form the basis of a press release from brap due 1 October 2007)
Although we are optimistic about the potential for the new Commission to provide our country with opportunities to refresh our thinking and practice on issues of equality, there is evidence that the inequalities gap is widening and we fear that a unique opportunity to make a real difference will be lost. If it is, then so too will the chance to conscientiously address the discrimination and inequality that affect the everyday lives and experiences of those many British people that exist at the sharp end of society. Because of this, discrimination and inequality thus blights all our lives.
To ensure we do not lose this opportunity, we need to move away from the recent preoccupation with ‘identity’ and ‘single’ identity politics: a point made in the Commission on Integration & Cohesion report, Shared futures. The constant focus on ‘Muslims’, for example, has meant that the ‘problem’ of extremism has become something that is seen to be about ‘them’ rather than ‘us’. Not only does this hinder the need for society as a whole to take a shared responsibility for equalities issues, but it also creates misunderstandings and barriers between us. As regards extremism in particular, this preoccupation with identity also obscures, rather than illuminates: acts of terrorism are criminal acts, committed by individuals, quite irrespective of the ideology they allege to purport. For the CEHR, continuing to focus on identity rather than inequality will be both incongruent and counter-productive, weakening rather than strengthening the kind of social cohesion most of us – including the Government - want to see: one where who I am will make me more disadvantaged than who you are.
Transitions are never easy. The CEHR should lead the way, pre-empting the typical knee-jerk responses by identifying the commonalities that exist between us: our commonalities as human beings first and foremost. To be successful, it must address the ‘issues’: those current barriers that prevent all of us from being treated equally. These are not necessarily going to be the same ‘issues’ as before, so letting go of the past will be a major hurdle.
With the establishment of the CEHR, we look forward to the challenges ahead and the opportunity to work together to extend and strengthen our shared understanding of what it is to be a citizen of Britain in the 21st century. To do this, we must not allow the crucial debates to be lost: the stakes are too high and the potential rewards too great.
(This entry will form the basis of a press release from brap due 1 October 2007)
Wednesday, 8 August 2007
The Tower: 'Regeneration is a form of ethnic cleansing'
Back in September 1989, Millwall Football Club unexpectedly announced that they were to follow Tottenham Hotspur and float themselves on the London Stock Exchange. In the Sun newspaper at the time, the former club chairman Reg Burr stated that he was not trying to turn the club into a 'yuppie' club.
At the same time, the Club were sponsored by the LDDC - the London Docklands Development Corporation.
The LDDC was a quango agency set up by the Thatcher Government in 1981 to 'regenerate' the Docklands areas of east and south east London. During its 18 year existence it was responsible for regenerating parts of the London Boroughs of Newham, Tower Hamlets and Southwark. It helped create Canary Wharf, Surrey Quays shopping centre, London City Airport, ExCeL Exhibition Centre and the Docklands Light Railway, bringing more than 120,000 new jobs to the Docklands and making the area highly sought after for housing.
Having lived in council housing all my life - as all my family and friends did at the time - the LDDC became known to me through their regeneration of the council estates that we lived on. Elim Estate where we lived was untouched due to the fact that it didn't have a 'river view'. But family who lived on Surrey Docks (now Surrey Quays/ Canada Water) and the Amos Estate were less fortunate. The LDDC bought the estate, moved everybody out of the area, giving them no say in whether they stayed or went and leaving Southwark Council with the task of rehousing them in less 'desirable' locations.
On hearing the announcement that Millwall was being floated on the Stock Exchange I was incensed enough to write a letter - well diatribe - to the South London Press to say that the imminent flotation was indicative of what was being played out all around us: the local people, like the local Club itself, were being exploited. The 'haves' were having more at the same time that the 'have nots' were having less.
At the time, nobody took me seriously. But visit the area now and you will see that under the guise of regeneration, the area is split more than ever along the lines of the 'haves' and 'have nots'. Those who can afford quarter of a million pounds apartments living in comfort and luxury to those living in rundown and neglected council housing below the poverty line.
Some 15 years before this, one of the places you might move to once you had a family of your own if you had been brought up on Elim or Amos estate was the Pepys Estate in Deptford. A large, sprawling estate punctuated by tower blocks, the estate overlooked the Thames. My second cousin, whose husband was later imprisoned for 'knee-capping' a Securicor van driver outside the C&A in Peckham, lived on the estate. At the time, we all felt that she was posh because of this.
Today, the Pepys Estate has gone down the route of many other council estates along the Thames and in the Docklands areas. Three years ago, Lewisham Council decided to sell the tower block closest to the Thames to private developers, Berkeley Homes. Since then, again under the guise of regeneration, the block has been emptied of the 144 people living in it so that it can be developed into a highly desirable residence with, as one resident put it, "a million dollar view". Before the private developers moved in, whilst the view was the same, the price would have been significantly lower. The building is now called the 'Z Building'.
From the other tower blocks of the Pepys Estate, the view is similar but tends to be from behind single glazed windows that are obscured by condensation and the mould that accompanies it. Despite offering a similar view, the apartments - known far less desirably as flats - are now far less sought after and instead of housing the wealthy, upwardly mobile elite, house the social outcasts and misfits that have ended up here as a result of their being less fortunate or even lucky.
'The Tower: a tale of two cities' is an eight part documentary series shown on BBC1 on Monday evenings. Filmed over three years, the series is full of real people that live on the estate: both those that live in the council owned blocks and those new residents seeking to make Deptford their new home. As one new resident put it, "The developers will make Deptford a much better place within five years. Just look at what they did with other areas - Hoxton was awful only a few years ago". Poignantly, the images that accompanied her words were of a handful of young black men being arrested by police at the foot of the recently developed building.
The series is a beautifully directed and constructed piece of documentary journalism. There are no whiffs of 'fly on the wall' overacting, no sense of anyone wanting to become 'celebrities', no need to 'doctor' the editing to make things more gritty. Instead, the series delves into the characters that comprise the Pepys Estate: sometimes disparate, sometimes desperate. The direction dips into and then out of different lives, leaving questions unanswered and on the whole, without the need for a silver lining. In many of these, I see the faces and characters of people that I know could be them. And because of this, I find the programme extremely watchable but at the same time, extremely sad which in turns makes me extremely angry. It shows real life - and death - for real people and that is not always comfortable viewing.
A recurrent image that crops up in different episodes is the graffiti of the title of this blog entry: 'Regeneration is a form of ethnic cleansing'. Seeing how people have been unwillingly and forcibly removed from their 'home' - no matter how dire or tragic that might be to the onlooker - the 'regeneration' of these and other areas has been and indeed continues to be little more than a form of ethnic cleansing. Maybe 'ethnic here is the wrong term. Instead, maybe 'class cleansing' is more appropriate.
Since the early 1980s, this form of cleansing has been systematic across much of inner London. Unconsciously we accept this and have done for more than two decades. But where do people like those from the Z Building go when they are forcibly removed from their homes? How many fall below the radar? How many disappear and end up, as the most recent episode captured so well, trapped with little else but to turn to such horrors as heroin, crack and so on?
Twenty years ago, maybe I foresaw the consequences of those such as the LDDC. For those who didn't believe me then, or don't believe me now, there's two more episodes of 'The Tower: a tale of two cities' before the end of the series. Don't miss the chance to see what other people's 'real life' looks like and decide whether 'regeneration' was a good or bad thing.
At the same time, the Club were sponsored by the LDDC - the London Docklands Development Corporation.
The LDDC was a quango agency set up by the Thatcher Government in 1981 to 'regenerate' the Docklands areas of east and south east London. During its 18 year existence it was responsible for regenerating parts of the London Boroughs of Newham, Tower Hamlets and Southwark. It helped create Canary Wharf, Surrey Quays shopping centre, London City Airport, ExCeL Exhibition Centre and the Docklands Light Railway, bringing more than 120,000 new jobs to the Docklands and making the area highly sought after for housing.
Having lived in council housing all my life - as all my family and friends did at the time - the LDDC became known to me through their regeneration of the council estates that we lived on. Elim Estate where we lived was untouched due to the fact that it didn't have a 'river view'. But family who lived on Surrey Docks (now Surrey Quays/ Canada Water) and the Amos Estate were less fortunate. The LDDC bought the estate, moved everybody out of the area, giving them no say in whether they stayed or went and leaving Southwark Council with the task of rehousing them in less 'desirable' locations.
On hearing the announcement that Millwall was being floated on the Stock Exchange I was incensed enough to write a letter - well diatribe - to the South London Press to say that the imminent flotation was indicative of what was being played out all around us: the local people, like the local Club itself, were being exploited. The 'haves' were having more at the same time that the 'have nots' were having less.
At the time, nobody took me seriously. But visit the area now and you will see that under the guise of regeneration, the area is split more than ever along the lines of the 'haves' and 'have nots'. Those who can afford quarter of a million pounds apartments living in comfort and luxury to those living in rundown and neglected council housing below the poverty line.
Some 15 years before this, one of the places you might move to once you had a family of your own if you had been brought up on Elim or Amos estate was the Pepys Estate in Deptford. A large, sprawling estate punctuated by tower blocks, the estate overlooked the Thames. My second cousin, whose husband was later imprisoned for 'knee-capping' a Securicor van driver outside the C&A in Peckham, lived on the estate. At the time, we all felt that she was posh because of this.
Today, the Pepys Estate has gone down the route of many other council estates along the Thames and in the Docklands areas. Three years ago, Lewisham Council decided to sell the tower block closest to the Thames to private developers, Berkeley Homes. Since then, again under the guise of regeneration, the block has been emptied of the 144 people living in it so that it can be developed into a highly desirable residence with, as one resident put it, "a million dollar view". Before the private developers moved in, whilst the view was the same, the price would have been significantly lower. The building is now called the 'Z Building'.
From the other tower blocks of the Pepys Estate, the view is similar but tends to be from behind single glazed windows that are obscured by condensation and the mould that accompanies it. Despite offering a similar view, the apartments - known far less desirably as flats - are now far less sought after and instead of housing the wealthy, upwardly mobile elite, house the social outcasts and misfits that have ended up here as a result of their being less fortunate or even lucky.
'The Tower: a tale of two cities' is an eight part documentary series shown on BBC1 on Monday evenings. Filmed over three years, the series is full of real people that live on the estate: both those that live in the council owned blocks and those new residents seeking to make Deptford their new home. As one new resident put it, "The developers will make Deptford a much better place within five years. Just look at what they did with other areas - Hoxton was awful only a few years ago". Poignantly, the images that accompanied her words were of a handful of young black men being arrested by police at the foot of the recently developed building.
The series is a beautifully directed and constructed piece of documentary journalism. There are no whiffs of 'fly on the wall' overacting, no sense of anyone wanting to become 'celebrities', no need to 'doctor' the editing to make things more gritty. Instead, the series delves into the characters that comprise the Pepys Estate: sometimes disparate, sometimes desperate. The direction dips into and then out of different lives, leaving questions unanswered and on the whole, without the need for a silver lining. In many of these, I see the faces and characters of people that I know could be them. And because of this, I find the programme extremely watchable but at the same time, extremely sad which in turns makes me extremely angry. It shows real life - and death - for real people and that is not always comfortable viewing.
A recurrent image that crops up in different episodes is the graffiti of the title of this blog entry: 'Regeneration is a form of ethnic cleansing'. Seeing how people have been unwillingly and forcibly removed from their 'home' - no matter how dire or tragic that might be to the onlooker - the 'regeneration' of these and other areas has been and indeed continues to be little more than a form of ethnic cleansing. Maybe 'ethnic here is the wrong term. Instead, maybe 'class cleansing' is more appropriate.
Since the early 1980s, this form of cleansing has been systematic across much of inner London. Unconsciously we accept this and have done for more than two decades. But where do people like those from the Z Building go when they are forcibly removed from their homes? How many fall below the radar? How many disappear and end up, as the most recent episode captured so well, trapped with little else but to turn to such horrors as heroin, crack and so on?
Twenty years ago, maybe I foresaw the consequences of those such as the LDDC. For those who didn't believe me then, or don't believe me now, there's two more episodes of 'The Tower: a tale of two cities' before the end of the series. Don't miss the chance to see what other people's 'real life' looks like and decide whether 'regeneration' was a good or bad thing.
Labels:
Deptford,
equalities,
Government policy,
LDDC,
Millwall
Friday, 27 July 2007
Beyond difference and towards community: a new approach to equalities
(This entry is a version of an article that will appear in the Birmingham Post within the next week)
Having watched the images of communities overcoming adversity as a result of the recent floods in Gloucestershire and Oxfordshire, you cannot help but empathise with the problems that the people living in those areas must have been facing. When events like this arise, many are quick to stress the sense of ‘community spirit’ that gets people through such times. In many ways this message can be reassuring, confirming to people that not only do communities still exist but that they are a positive influence and force for good in our rapidly changing society. Very few people would disagree with this. Yet if you look closely at the television images of those queuing for fresh water, you will see that the people themselves are widely diverse and different: a ‘community of communities’ maybe. Yet despite this vast diversity and difference, the same old sense of ‘community’ and what’s good about it appears to remain.
The dictionary definition of a ‘community’ is one where people live together in one place, sometimes with a sense of common ownership. In more recent years however, there has been a tendency to use the term ‘community’ to lump people together on the basis of their identity, stressing this aspect of the definition in preference of those merely living together in one place. This has meant that on far too many occasions, people are seen to be a community because of who or what they are rather than anything else. In doing so, the increasingly popular notion of community overlooks or even eradicates that necessary recognition of diversity and difference that vibrant and real communities – such as those overcoming adversity together in Gloucestershire or in today’s Birmingham - typically contain.
In terms of Birmingham, if we think that the people living together today are diverse, in the coming decade the city and its inhabitants will become ‘super-diverse’. To ensure that Birmingham as community therefore remains a force for good, ensuring that everyone is treated equally will become increasingly central to the city’s ongoing success.
If this is not achieved, then a lack of equality and the division of people into single identity communities could be easily used to not only identify but more worryingly single out and even scapegoat particular sections of society. This is far from being mere speculation, we only have to look back over recent months to see how events in Birmingham cause some to hold their breath in the hope that a concerted backlash against certain groups of people fail to materialise. For Birmingham as indeed elsewhere, this understanding of community can be problematic and can play into the hands of the mischief-makers who want to exploit the tensions and fractures that also clearly exist. When social and community challenges therefore arise, for many in society those challenges and ‘problems’ belong to ‘them’ rather than ‘us’. In doing so, not only do we see ‘them’ as being clearly different from ‘us’, but we also see ‘them’ presenting a challenge to ‘us’ in terms of ‘our’ values, way of life, culture and so on. Because of this, not all people in our community are treated equally.
This attitude and approach to understanding and identifying difference is sometimes reinforced both in politics and also by spokespeople for particular groups, or dare I say it, different ‘communities’. Take for instance the Government’s Preventing Extremism Together (PET) programme that is currently being rolled out across Birmingham in the form of projects (like raising awareness of Islam and training Imams). By funding ‘Muslim’ groups and ‘Muslim’ initiatives only, the programme runs the risk of inadvertently attributing the ‘problem’ of extremism to Muslim communities alone. In this way extremism – and more importantly preventing extremism – becomes something for most people in the city that is more about ‘them’ than it is about ‘us’.
With the emphasis being placed upon what Muslims should be doing, an opportunity is being squandered that might allow society as a whole to take a shared responsibility for ‘preventing extremism together’ through promoting common ownership of the problem. An approach that sees people and communities as having a ‘single identity’ alone was recently identified as problematic in the findings of the recent Commission on Integration & Cohesion’s report. Shared futures, as the report was titled, stressed the need to put an emphasis on articulating what binds communities together rather than the differences that might divide them. In prioritising a shared future over divided legacies, the report stressed that funding single identity groups or single issue projects can be regressive and divisive. Birmingham’s PET therefore seems to go against current thinking about what is good for communities.
In part, the approach to PET reflects the way Government and Local Authorities have sought to engage with black and minority ethnic (BME) communities in the past. This approach was known as ‘representation’ and was on many occasions highlighted as having serious flaws, Often used to advocate and lobby on behalf of the views and interests of those given the opportunity to ‘represent’, this has historically encouraged groups to play up their victimhood as well as their unique cultural or religious identities in a bid for more public funds or greater social influence. In a programme like PET, this can have a number of negative effects. Most significantly, divisions can be reinforced at the same time as encouraging some to believe that Muslims for example are getting preferential treatment. Consider for example the ‘grants for Muslims’ statistics used by the far-right in some of their campaign materials in certain areas of the outer city recently. Ultimately, such approaches can result in all people feeling that they are not being treated equally.
Because of this, few in society ‘buy-in’ to the challenges and problems we face in terms of ensuring all people are treated equally: few share that common ownership necessary to build a community. Yet as we saw in Gloucester, the consequences of the problems that impact upon communities affect us all, quite irrespective of what any of our differences may or may not be. The flood waters therefore failed to recognise ‘them’ and ‘us’ and so impacted upon the lives of white and black, young and old, male and female, Christian, Muslim, atheist and the not sure (as well as those who just don’t care!). Irrespective of who or what the people are that are queuing for fresh water, all that mattered was that everyone was treated equally. Whilst the challenges facing those in Birmingham may then have a different dynamic or focus, what really matters is that all are treated equally no matter what that challenge or situation might be.
Is it time then for a new approach to treating all people equally and by default, strengthening community?
As Director of Research and Policy at BRAP – a Birmingham based equalities and human rights charity – much of this is central to our day-to-day thinking. Because of this, we have been at the forefront of the shift towards a human rights based approach to equalities. Historically, equalities legislation in the UK has been largely driven in response to incidents that have had a nationwide resonance, for example the Brixton riots in 1981 and the murder of Stephen Lawrence in 1993. This has typically led to some form of protection being afforded to particular groups, such as ethnic minorities for example. While this has helped to rightfully protect some people, others have not been able to benefit because they have not met a particular identity or ‘profile’, something that is entirely divisive. And even for those offered some form of protection, it has not always been the case that simply reducing discrimination has been enough to prevent ongoing inequalities.
This is where a human rights based approach to equalities offers some benefits over and above what we already have. Human rights are ‘inherent’, they don’t need to be earned or bought. So groups shouldn’t have to wait for a riot or for somebody to die in order to be afforded the protection they deserve. Also human rights are universal, and all people can have them irrespective of their identity. This approach disposes of the need for knee-jerk responses and may even go some way towards identifying the commonalities that exist between us: commonalities between us as human beings first and foremost.
The slow and albeit tentative shift towards a human rights approach to equalities will gain further momentum later this year with the formation of the Commission for Equality and Human Rights (CEHR) in October. For the first time in Britain, the various equalities strands covering ‘race’, gender, disability, age, sexual orientation as well as religion and belief will be brought together. By moving beyond the single identities that existing approaches have preferred – including PET – we can begin to address the ‘issues’ that stop us from feeling as though we are treated equally and that cause us to blame or scapegoat others as a result.
There remains a long way to go however, but if we want to build a community with a shared future, equalities and human rights might just be the unifier – the common ownership element – that our changing society needs. Building upon what informs our understanding of ‘community’ and what’s good about it might then be the first step in a new direction towards the goal of seeing everyone as ‘us’ in preference of others being ‘them’. To ensure that people see the value of treating everyone equally, those involved in driving equalities will need to effectively communicate what this might be and what a human rights based approach to equalities might look like for all. To do this, we must ensure that we not only speak out when certain groups are scapegoated or unnecessarily targeted but also when programmes such as the PET go against current sensibilities and flout potentially divisive lines. In doing this, community will go beyond being about what you are or on what basis you are lumped together, but more importantly about treating those we live together with equally and fairly irrespective of difference or diversity.
Having watched the images of communities overcoming adversity as a result of the recent floods in Gloucestershire and Oxfordshire, you cannot help but empathise with the problems that the people living in those areas must have been facing. When events like this arise, many are quick to stress the sense of ‘community spirit’ that gets people through such times. In many ways this message can be reassuring, confirming to people that not only do communities still exist but that they are a positive influence and force for good in our rapidly changing society. Very few people would disagree with this. Yet if you look closely at the television images of those queuing for fresh water, you will see that the people themselves are widely diverse and different: a ‘community of communities’ maybe. Yet despite this vast diversity and difference, the same old sense of ‘community’ and what’s good about it appears to remain.
The dictionary definition of a ‘community’ is one where people live together in one place, sometimes with a sense of common ownership. In more recent years however, there has been a tendency to use the term ‘community’ to lump people together on the basis of their identity, stressing this aspect of the definition in preference of those merely living together in one place. This has meant that on far too many occasions, people are seen to be a community because of who or what they are rather than anything else. In doing so, the increasingly popular notion of community overlooks or even eradicates that necessary recognition of diversity and difference that vibrant and real communities – such as those overcoming adversity together in Gloucestershire or in today’s Birmingham - typically contain.
In terms of Birmingham, if we think that the people living together today are diverse, in the coming decade the city and its inhabitants will become ‘super-diverse’. To ensure that Birmingham as community therefore remains a force for good, ensuring that everyone is treated equally will become increasingly central to the city’s ongoing success.
If this is not achieved, then a lack of equality and the division of people into single identity communities could be easily used to not only identify but more worryingly single out and even scapegoat particular sections of society. This is far from being mere speculation, we only have to look back over recent months to see how events in Birmingham cause some to hold their breath in the hope that a concerted backlash against certain groups of people fail to materialise. For Birmingham as indeed elsewhere, this understanding of community can be problematic and can play into the hands of the mischief-makers who want to exploit the tensions and fractures that also clearly exist. When social and community challenges therefore arise, for many in society those challenges and ‘problems’ belong to ‘them’ rather than ‘us’. In doing so, not only do we see ‘them’ as being clearly different from ‘us’, but we also see ‘them’ presenting a challenge to ‘us’ in terms of ‘our’ values, way of life, culture and so on. Because of this, not all people in our community are treated equally.
This attitude and approach to understanding and identifying difference is sometimes reinforced both in politics and also by spokespeople for particular groups, or dare I say it, different ‘communities’. Take for instance the Government’s Preventing Extremism Together (PET) programme that is currently being rolled out across Birmingham in the form of projects (like raising awareness of Islam and training Imams). By funding ‘Muslim’ groups and ‘Muslim’ initiatives only, the programme runs the risk of inadvertently attributing the ‘problem’ of extremism to Muslim communities alone. In this way extremism – and more importantly preventing extremism – becomes something for most people in the city that is more about ‘them’ than it is about ‘us’.
With the emphasis being placed upon what Muslims should be doing, an opportunity is being squandered that might allow society as a whole to take a shared responsibility for ‘preventing extremism together’ through promoting common ownership of the problem. An approach that sees people and communities as having a ‘single identity’ alone was recently identified as problematic in the findings of the recent Commission on Integration & Cohesion’s report. Shared futures, as the report was titled, stressed the need to put an emphasis on articulating what binds communities together rather than the differences that might divide them. In prioritising a shared future over divided legacies, the report stressed that funding single identity groups or single issue projects can be regressive and divisive. Birmingham’s PET therefore seems to go against current thinking about what is good for communities.
In part, the approach to PET reflects the way Government and Local Authorities have sought to engage with black and minority ethnic (BME) communities in the past. This approach was known as ‘representation’ and was on many occasions highlighted as having serious flaws, Often used to advocate and lobby on behalf of the views and interests of those given the opportunity to ‘represent’, this has historically encouraged groups to play up their victimhood as well as their unique cultural or religious identities in a bid for more public funds or greater social influence. In a programme like PET, this can have a number of negative effects. Most significantly, divisions can be reinforced at the same time as encouraging some to believe that Muslims for example are getting preferential treatment. Consider for example the ‘grants for Muslims’ statistics used by the far-right in some of their campaign materials in certain areas of the outer city recently. Ultimately, such approaches can result in all people feeling that they are not being treated equally.
Because of this, few in society ‘buy-in’ to the challenges and problems we face in terms of ensuring all people are treated equally: few share that common ownership necessary to build a community. Yet as we saw in Gloucester, the consequences of the problems that impact upon communities affect us all, quite irrespective of what any of our differences may or may not be. The flood waters therefore failed to recognise ‘them’ and ‘us’ and so impacted upon the lives of white and black, young and old, male and female, Christian, Muslim, atheist and the not sure (as well as those who just don’t care!). Irrespective of who or what the people are that are queuing for fresh water, all that mattered was that everyone was treated equally. Whilst the challenges facing those in Birmingham may then have a different dynamic or focus, what really matters is that all are treated equally no matter what that challenge or situation might be.
Is it time then for a new approach to treating all people equally and by default, strengthening community?
As Director of Research and Policy at BRAP – a Birmingham based equalities and human rights charity – much of this is central to our day-to-day thinking. Because of this, we have been at the forefront of the shift towards a human rights based approach to equalities. Historically, equalities legislation in the UK has been largely driven in response to incidents that have had a nationwide resonance, for example the Brixton riots in 1981 and the murder of Stephen Lawrence in 1993. This has typically led to some form of protection being afforded to particular groups, such as ethnic minorities for example. While this has helped to rightfully protect some people, others have not been able to benefit because they have not met a particular identity or ‘profile’, something that is entirely divisive. And even for those offered some form of protection, it has not always been the case that simply reducing discrimination has been enough to prevent ongoing inequalities.
This is where a human rights based approach to equalities offers some benefits over and above what we already have. Human rights are ‘inherent’, they don’t need to be earned or bought. So groups shouldn’t have to wait for a riot or for somebody to die in order to be afforded the protection they deserve. Also human rights are universal, and all people can have them irrespective of their identity. This approach disposes of the need for knee-jerk responses and may even go some way towards identifying the commonalities that exist between us: commonalities between us as human beings first and foremost.
The slow and albeit tentative shift towards a human rights approach to equalities will gain further momentum later this year with the formation of the Commission for Equality and Human Rights (CEHR) in October. For the first time in Britain, the various equalities strands covering ‘race’, gender, disability, age, sexual orientation as well as religion and belief will be brought together. By moving beyond the single identities that existing approaches have preferred – including PET – we can begin to address the ‘issues’ that stop us from feeling as though we are treated equally and that cause us to blame or scapegoat others as a result.
There remains a long way to go however, but if we want to build a community with a shared future, equalities and human rights might just be the unifier – the common ownership element – that our changing society needs. Building upon what informs our understanding of ‘community’ and what’s good about it might then be the first step in a new direction towards the goal of seeing everyone as ‘us’ in preference of others being ‘them’. To ensure that people see the value of treating everyone equally, those involved in driving equalities will need to effectively communicate what this might be and what a human rights based approach to equalities might look like for all. To do this, we must ensure that we not only speak out when certain groups are scapegoated or unnecessarily targeted but also when programmes such as the PET go against current sensibilities and flout potentially divisive lines. In doing this, community will go beyond being about what you are or on what basis you are lumped together, but more importantly about treating those we live together with equally and fairly irrespective of difference or diversity.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
