Showing posts with label Search for Common Ground. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Search for Common Ground. Show all posts

Monday, 19 November 2007

Guardian Media: What Muslim journalists think about the UK media

Good old Laura, she's still battling away at trying to get some good PR for the 'Search for Common Ground' report. Flogging a dead horse given the size and number of the 'enemies'? Who knows...


Guardian reporter Laura Smith spoke to journalists from Muslim backgrounds about how they felt about the mainstream media's coverage of Islam and their place in the industry
November 19, 2007 4:05 PM

Last year, I interviewed journalists from Muslim backgrounds about their experiences working within the mainstream press, writes Laura Smith. At a time when opinion about Muslims takes up a great deal of space in newspapers, I was interested to find out how they felt about this coverage and about their own role in it.

The results of those six interviews, conducted alongside the Guardian's Hugh Muir and published last week in the Greater London Authority report The Search for Common Ground: Muslims, non-Muslims and the UK media, make thought-provoking reading.

Most of the journalists we spoke to had been brought up with the suspicion that the media was biased - a sense not helped by coverage of the Salman Rushdie affair in the late 1980s. But only one had entered the profession with a conscious aim to alter portrayal of Muslims and Islam. The rest gave a range of reasons, from "I'm really nosey" to "I thought it was an interesting career".

Once working within newsrooms, however, most found it impossible to ignore the way their religious identities were perceived - especially after the terrorist attacks of September 11 2001 and July 7 2005. The way they coped varied.

Some put their heads down and tried to stick to stories that did not involve such subjects. "The thing is I don't want to be pigeon-holed. I'm a professional journalist, not a professional Paki", was how one put it. Others began to use their position to contribute to more balanced coverage. One reporter, who had thought she could leave her Muslim identity "in a box away from my role as a journalist" found herself drawn to exploring it. Another put it like this: "I have been thrown into writing about Muslim issues rather than having a massive interest in them. But I'd rather do it than let anyone else do it because I am more aware of the issues. Otherwise you get stuck with stereotypes."

There were, of course, advantages to being, in many cases, the only Muslim journalist in the building. Several spoke of becoming a "valuable commodity" to the newsdesk and finding themselves with a new status. Others said they had been able to bring in stories other journalists were unable to access - "I can see why it might be reasonable for me rather than Bob Jones to go undercover at Finsbury Park" was how one put it - and of having a positive influence on the way Muslim issues were reported.

But there were pitfalls too, with more than one regarding reporting on such issues as a "gilded cage" or a "cul-de-sac". The assumption that they knew more than they did was also problematic. One reporter told me: "People assume that because of my name I know about Islamic society... the religion, the language, the background. The reality is quite different." "I haven't got a magic hotline to Osama or Bakri Mohammed," said another. "People think I must know people and I'm hiding it. Of the Muslims I know, 99% of them are my relatives."

The struggle to retain their integrity, an issue facing all journalists, was particularly fraught. More than one journalist we spoke to had been asked to infiltrate al-Qaida, and regarded the idea with incredulity. Others felt they had compromised their religious beliefs. One said he felt like a "charlatan" attending mosques to pick up stories, while another said of a particularly difficult incident: "I felt I had used my Muslim background for my own glory but I didn't have the confidence to say I was really upset about it."

Despite strong feelings about being in such a minority among reporters ("There are times when I just want to leave and do something where I am not this token Asian", said one), they were on the whole wary of calling for 'more Muslim journalists' to improve coverage. Most called instead for a more representative workforce in general - "If journalism is about finding out the view from the ground then class is as important as race or religion", said one - and for all journalists to educate themselves, whatever their background. As one put it: "It's up to the journalists to be more aware about the country we live in."

Sunday, 18 November 2007

Inside the inner sanctum of 'The Search for Common Ground'

Let's be honest...there ARE problems with the report.

In my chapter - chapter 2 - a lot of relevant information is overlooked or edited out including two very important pieces, especially if you've read the criticisms shown on this blog.

First, the report fails to include the typology employed to highlight how 'positive', 'negative' and 'neutral' were identified, leaving a void that the critics have rightly capitalised upon.

Second, the report fails to include the overwhelming fact that in comparison with research that was undertaken a mere decade ago by Elizabeth Poole, the amount of articles about Islam and Muslims in the press has increased by nearly 270%. This piece of information alone is staggering and why it was left out of the final publication absolutely astounds me.

Some other criticisms that I think are fair include the fact that the report...

Was edited, edited and re-edited, then left for months, then edited, edited and...you get the picture;
Had - in my opinion - been the subject of too much behind closed doors politic-ing and was used - or not - accordingly;
Was somewhat out of date by the time it came to press;
Focused on far too many things that were 'personal' (interpret that as you see fit) to some of those involved and/or commissioning it;
And - along with the al-Qaradawi chapter that was sensibly axed - needed to have the Panorama chapter cut or at least heavily edited also.

There were also a lot of people named in the writing of the report that if honest, rarely attended the meetings and so wonder what their retrospective influence/ involvement was. Were they the ones inside the report's inner sanctum? Who knows...

Maybe all this is a little controversial and too soon after the report's publication to be completely objective, but could it be that this report is open to the same criticisms that I made in my 'The first decade of Islamophobia' think-piece? Surely if nothing else, we need to re-think how we talk about Islamophobia if nothing else...

Actually, if you take the chapter out about the Panorama programme, the report is not much worse than many other reports that see the light of day. It just seems to be who were or at least perceived to have been pulling the strings that has caused the problems.

Further evidence for me to think that it's not worth getting involved in work such as this...

Spiked: London’s PC despot - in the name of combating 'Islamophobia', Ken Livingstone has launched an attack on press freedom that reveals his fear

And another one about the 'Search for Common Ground' report...it's very difficult to distinguish between where actual criticism begins and the 'politic-ing' mentioned previously ends. One thing though, there is a lot of criticism about the report and that is on the version that had the chapter about the visit by Yusuf al-Qaradwai cut from it !!! Imagine what the response would have been had that been included too...


What kind of leader launches an open assault on the press, accusing it of jeopardising public safety and demanding that it put its ‘house in order’? What sort of ruler proposes ‘guidelines’ to the press on what stories it should cover, and even worse, what kind of language it should use to cover them, what kind of people it should employ, and what kind of values it should uphold and communicate to the mass of the population? Kim Jong-il, perhaps? Saddam Hussein, before he was chased into his hole in the ground and later executed? How about Ken Livingstone, the mayor of London?

This week, ‘Red Ken’, as some people insist on calling him, launched a report on British media coverage of ‘Muslim issues’. Titled The Search for Common Ground: Muslims, Non-Muslims and the UK Media, the report was commissioned by Livingstone’s Greater London Authority. It explores the alleged rise of Islamophobia in the media. And in the name of tackling the apparent spread of prejudice through the papers (especially tabloid ones), Livingstone and his supporters have crossed a line normally only transgressed by despots: they’re using their political clout to try to shape the media in their own image. Strip away all the PC lingo about ‘protecting Muslims’, and the London mayor’s latest initiative comes across as an intolerable attack on press freedom.

The report argues that Islamophobia is rampant in the British press, and that new attitudes amongst journalists and codes of ethics will be required to deal with it. In his foreword, Livingstone argues that there is an increasingly ‘negative portrayal of Muslims and Islam in the media’, which is helping to ‘[sow] divisions among London’s diverse communities’ (pxi). Elsewhere, the report argues that such coverage means ‘Muslims understandably feel vulnerable to hate crimes and unlawful discrimination’; indeed, the ‘drip-drip-drip’ repetition of ‘abusive and emotive language’ about Muslims could lead to ‘more hate crimes and acts of discrimination than otherwise’ (p128). In short, the media’s irresponsible coverage of Muslim issues is a threat to social cohesion and a potential harbinger of violence.

In fact, the report uses questionable, one might even say dodgy methodology to show that the media are continually ‘abusing’ Muslims. For chapter 2 – ‘A normal week? Threats and crises in Britain and the world’ – the report’s authors select a ‘random’ week in 2006 and assess the newspapers’ coverage of Muslim affairs during that week. They chose Monday 8 May to Sunday 14 May 2006. During this week there were apparently 352 articles on Muslim-related issues in all the mainstream daily newspapers. The report’s authors found that of these 352 articles, 91 per cent were ‘negative’ in their portrayal of Muslims and Islam, and only four per cent were judged to be positive. Five per cent were judged neutral. This is evidence, the report claims, of the ‘demonisation’ of Muslims by a ‘torrent’ of negative stories (p18).

It pays – a lot – to look more closely at how this research was carried out. First, the random week selected by the researchers happened to be the week in which the government published its report on the 7/7 bombings. That report came out on Friday 12 May. Not surprisingly, there was a huge amount of press coverage, and not surprisingly most of it was ‘negative’, in the sense that it was about four British-born Muslims who blew up themselves and 52 others in London a year earlier; even individuals of an old Stalinist bent, such as those who stack’s Livingstone’s GLA, would find it hard to put a ‘positive’ spin on such a story. Of the study’s 352 newspaper stories related to Muslims, 69 – or 19.6 per cent – were about the 7/7 bombings (p26).

What’s more, the researchers made a broad sweep indeed when selecting articles ‘about Muslims’. They counted all articles that included the words ‘Islam’, ‘Muslims’, ‘Islamic’, ‘Islamist’, ‘Sunni’, ‘Shia’, or the words ‘radical’, ‘fundamentalist’ and ‘extremist’ if the ‘context was such that it was reasonable to assume that an association with Islam or Muslims would be made’. In other words, even an article about an ‘extremist’ online al-Qaeda sympathiser, say, could be selected as a negative story about Muslims, even if it did not say anything about his religious identity (p17). The researchers also included articles where the names of people were obviously Muslim, ‘even if their religious identity was not explicitly stated’. This leads to a bizarre situation where articles about the sentencing of the former boxer Prince Naseem for dangerous driving are included as part of the torrent of negative stories about Muslims. Naseem was sentenced to 15 months in prison in the week selected by the researchers (on 12 May 2006), and because his name (Naseem Hamed) is obviously Muslim, and because the stories (on dangerous driving) are obviously negative, they are added to the pile of evidence that the media are abusing Muslims. Of the 352 articles selected by the researchers, 15, or 4.3 per cent, were ‘negative’ stories about Prince Naseem (p26).

Even worse, in selecting articles that include the words ‘Sunni’ and ‘Shia’, the researchers included all of that random week’s coverage of the bloody mess that is postwar Iraq. May 2006 was the bloodiest month of the year so far in Iraq: according to the Iraq Body Count website, between 2,000 and 2,100 people were killed in Iraq during that month. Not surprisingly, articles about Iraq come second only to articles about 7/7 in the researchers’ list of ‘negative stories on Muslims’. Of their 352 selected articles, 49 – or 13.9 per cent – were news articles about the violence and instability in Iraq. Here, even reporting about a bloody foreign war, which might not necessarily mention ‘Muslims’ but by necessity mentions the words ‘Sunni’ and ‘Shia’, is cited as an example of irresponsible and abusive media content on Muslims.

What are the researchers saying? That coverage of things like Iraq and 7/7 needs to be more positive? That journalists who write on war and rare acts of terrorism should mind their language lest they offend Muslims? Or more to the point, lest they offend those who fancy themselves, through the power of self-selection rather than anything so grubby as an electoral process, to be the representatives of Muslims. The contributors to Livingstone’s report include Inayat Bunglawala of the Muslim Council of Britain, Mohammed Abdul Aziz of the Forum Against Islamophobia and Racism, and Tariq Hameed, who writes reports for the Muslim Council of Britain on how journalists should cover Muslim affairs. Are these individuals so narcissistic that they read about the debacle in Iraq and think only of their personal feelings?

In labelling as ‘negative’ and ‘abusive’ even stories about war and terrorism, the report’s authors show their deeply censorious streak. They are effectively updating, in PC terminology, the old BBC man Martyn Lewis’s demand in the 1990s for more ‘happy news’. Where Lewis said news reporters should seek out ‘good news stories’ as well as bad news stories, effectively spreading the ‘And Finally’ bit of News at Ten across the whole news agenda, Ken’s researchers label everything from coverage of Prince Naseem to the war in Iraq as overly negative, and demand more positive stories on Muslim affairs. This is a demand for the press to overhaul its agenda, for journalists to shift their focus, change their language, and, as the report says, ‘contribute to informed discussion and debate amongst Muslims and non-Muslims about ways of working together to maintain and develop Britain as a multicultural, multifaith democracy’ (pxiv). In short, the press should do the kind of thing that Livingstone wants it to. It speaks volumes about Livingstone’s arrogance and contempt for public debate that he would like to, if only he had the power, turn the press into an offshoot of his political fiefdom.

So, the demonisation of Muslims in the media does not normally consist of articles attacking or slurring Muslims – rather it consists of news reports on Iraq, 7/7, Prince Naseem, as well as Iran, Palestine and numerous other newsworthy issues. Thus, the authors of the report are forced to trawl the dodgier regions of the tabloid media for what they consider to be truly disturbing examples of anti-Muslim prejudice. In chapter 3 – ‘Britishness is being destroyed: worries in a changing world’ – they flag up examples of the media abuse of Muslims. The main example – make sure you are sitting comfortably – appeared on the front page of the Daily Express in October 2005. It was headlined: ‘HOGWASH: Now the PC brigade bans piggy banks in case they upset Muslims.’ The report spends five pages discussing and dissecting this silly but fairly typical ‘PC gone mad’ story that the vast majority of us will have shrugged off at the time and certainly forgotten about since. In total, chapter 3 breaks down what the authors admit are ‘four small episodes’, ‘each relatively trivial in itself’ – that is, all of them are tabloid-style ‘PC gone mad’ stories – yet cites them as evidence that there is an ‘attack on Muslims’ in the media (p31).

The authors then get really desperate. Unable to find many clear expressions of serious anti-Muslim prejudice in the mainstream, they move on to the online discussion boards of the tabloid newspapers. On the Daily Express website they find that web-users have written things like ‘I am sick to the back teeth of hearing about Muslims this and Muslims that’; ‘The Islamic tail is wagging the British bulldog’; and ‘Instead of assimilating into our culture, Muslims whine and complain… They should return to the homeland of their beloved prophet Mohammed.’ (p11) Clearly some of these statements were written by individuals with noxious views. But material posted on the free-for-all discussion boards of the Daily Express website hardly represents a mainstream torrent of abuse. If I took seriously everything that was ever said about me on online discussion boards, I’d never leave the house. That the researchers had to trawl the gutters of the World Wide Web in order to find abuse of Muslims (and even here, the abuse cited is fairly mild) shows that ‘Islamophobia’ is not a mainstream or powerful prejudice. Yet the researchers seem desperate to demonstrate that it is. That is because this report looks to me less like an attempt to tackle real prejudice than to propose some quite authoritarian ideas under the guise of ‘tackling Islamophobia’.

This report demonstrates what the phenomenon of Islamophobia is actually about today. There has been no public groundswell in anti-Muslim prejudice, or in anti-Muslim violence; rather, the spectre of ‘Islamophobia’ exists in the minds of the elite, who look upon Britain’s white working-class communities as an unpredictable blob liable to carry out acts of violence against Muslims if they read an article about piggy banks being banned or Prince Naseem being jailed. The Islamophobia agenda, as pushed by central government, the GLA, the police, various self-selected Muslim community groups and, as it happens, large sections of the media itself, is underpinned by a poisonous view of the masses as irrational and given to violent outbursts, and Muslims as pathetic victims who need heroic Ken and his handpicked Muslim community warriors to protect them. That is why this report focuses mostly on the tabloids, because, as it says, these papers are read by ‘millions’ of people. Those horrible, hard-to-predict millions; we can’t have them reading inflammatory material, can we? (pxvii)

The report says that media coverage may lead to increased violence, yet all the evidence suggests that there has not been a rise in anti-Muslim attacks. At the end of last year, the Crown Prosecution Service revealed that in 2005-2006 – in the aftermath of the 7/7 bombings, when politicians, the police and others predicted there would be an anti-Muslim pogrom – there were only 43 cases of religiously aggravated crime, 18 of them against Muslims (or ‘perceived’ Muslims). This represented a decline from 23 anti-Muslim crimes in 2004-2005 (1). It is the irrational fear of public opinion that is widespread in the GLA and elsewhere that leads some to see a connection between fairly ordinary media coverage of important events and a possible rise in violence. The truth is that Livingstone’s desire to police the language that journalists use, just as central government has tried to curb the language all of us use in relation to ‘religious hatred’, does nothing to rejuvenate or improve communuty relations or public life; instead it allows ideas to fester, unchallenged.

Common Ground, with its strange methodology, cliquish community group input and fear of tabloids and tabloid readers, ends by calling for an overhaul of the media. It calls for ‘codes of professional conduct and style guides about use of terminology’; for the employment of ‘more journalists of Muslim heritage who can more accurately reflect the views and experiences of Muslim communities’; and for the Commission for Equality and Human Rights and the government’s Department for Communities and Local Government to focus on ‘combating anti-Muslim prejudice in the media’ and in ‘the general climate of public opinion’ (p133). These are explicit demands for increased government intervention into the press, and anyone who believes in the freedom of the press should rigorously oppose them and hope that the government ignores them.

Of course there are vast problems with the British press, its tendency to scaremonger about the threat of terrorism amongst them. Yet as Karl Marx, history’s most passionate and consistent defender of freedom of the press, argued, a ‘bad’ free press is better than a ‘good’ controlled press. Marx said: ‘The free press remains good even when its products are bad, because these products are deviations from the nature of a free press, [while] the censored press remains bad, even when its products are good, because these products are only good insofar as they represent the free press within the censored press’ (2). Marx ridiculed nineteenth-century European rulers who argued that the press should be restricted because it threatened the ‘public good’ and who called on newspapers to hire only ‘respectable’ individuals whose ‘position and character guarantee the seriousness of their activities and the loyalty of their thinking’ (3). Livingstone, if he had the power, would do precisely these two things. He argues that the media is ‘sowing divisions’ and ‘harming social cohesion’ – that is, threatening public safety – and his report goes so far as to suggest who the media should employ: more Muslims, who apparently have the expertise and the loyalty to uphold the multicultural vision.

There is something archaically tyrannical in Livingstone’s vision for the press: on the basis of questionable findings, he and his supporters express their desire to cajole the media into promoting the Livingstone vision for society, which is the ‘building and maintenance of Britain as a multicultural society’ (pxiii). If Livingstone got his way, it would represent an explicit politicisation of the media, though it would be done under the guise of representing the interests of Muslim communities and the British people more broadly. Yet as Marx said, in a controlled or censored media, the government ‘hears only its own voice, knows that it hears only its own voice, and is yet fixed on the delusion to hear the voice of the people...’ (4) The press should remain free from all forms of delusional interference by the authorities. Our current bad media – fairly free, messy, a bit mad, but which represents at least an aspiration to independence and objectivity – is a million times better than Livingstone’s vision of a calm, slavish and unquestioning ‘good media’ could ever be.

Brendan O’Neill is editor of spiked. Visit his website here.

(1) See Hands up if you’re suffering from Islamofatigue, by Brendan O’Neill

(2) Communication and Freedom: Karl Marx on Press Freedom and Censorship, Hanno Hardt, The Public, Vol.7 (2000)

(3) Communication and Freedom: Karl Marx on Press Freedom and Censorship, Hanno Hardt, The Public, Vol.7 (2000)

(4) Communication and Freedom: Karl Marx on Press Freedom and Censorship, Hanno Hardt, The Public, Vol.7 (2000)

Sunday Telegraph: Am I the demoniser… or is it Ken's 'experts'?

It's so popular this 'Search for Common Ground' report...but for all the wrong reasons!!! Here's another response to the report and it's findings.

The Muslim Council of Britain (MCB) claims to be "the most reasonable and most representative spokesperson for the British Muslim community". Unlike most religious organisations, it is also explicitly political. The MCB has opinions on everything, from school uniforms to the NHS; from the recall of Parliament to the extradition to the US of Babar Ahmad. And it is not shy about lobbying for them.

Political Islam is relatively new to Britain. It's an important development. The MCB complains of "demonisation" when journalists criticise it, yet the MCB's response to its media critics seems often to be to "demonise" them. At least, it felt like that when it happened to me. I've been called an "Islamophobe", a "Zionist" and an "enemy of Islam" by the MCB; a "kufaar" and "a low caste koolie journalist" on another Muslim website.

Why? In the wake of the 7/7 bombings, I made a BBC Panorama programme in which I was crystal clear that Muslim leaders had unreservedly condemned the bombings. But four leading Muslims also argued that the MCB's leadership was in denial about the causes and the extent of extremism, which I suggested fed off a conviction that Islam is a superior faith and culture that Christians and Jews in the West are conspiring to undermine.
advertisement

The programme subjected the MCB to the kind of questioning and inquiry to which the press has a duty to subject every politically significant organisation. But only last week, Ken Livingstone, the Mayor of London, unveiled a report into media "Islamophobia" which he had commissioned and which was highly critical of the programme - a programme which the Mayor had condemned as "a witch hunt... of demonisation and spin" even before it had been edited.

Criticism of my Panorama programme made up a quarter of the report written by "nine leading academics, professionals from the media industry and experts on Islam". Mr Livingstone believes the report demonstrates how "ignorance, prejudice and Islamophobia" is "stirred up by some sections of the media" has "overwhelmingly portrayed Muslims and Islam in a negative way". His experts said the programme "did not facilitate or support the level of debate that is required". In fact it provoked a great deal of debate. But the result wasn't the one the MCB wanted: a year after the programme, Tony Blair ended the Government's special relationship with the MCB as its interlocutor of choice for contacts with the Muslim community in Britain.

Who were the three "experts on Islam" who helped to produce the report? Surprise, surprise: they all turn out to be from the MCB. There has been some silly and offensive coverage of Islam in the press, but the report's authors provided no evidence at all that the Panorama programme was part of it. Broadening out from the documentary, they claimed that in "a typical week", over 90 per cent of the 352 articles in 20 national daily and Sunday papers that "referred to Islam and Muslims were negative". But the week they chose - the second week in May, 2006 - was anything but typical. It was the week when the Government published its reports on the 7/7 bombing, and it was the week in which Iran announced it would continue its nuclear development programme. Those events probably go a long way to explain the number of "negative" reports, many of which were simply factual.

Mr Livingstone and his "experts" insist that the way Islam is covered in the media deepens divisions, causing Muslims to feel "vulnerable and alienated" and giving non-Muslims "increased feelings of insecurity, suspicion and anxiety". Their solution? The Press Complaints Commission should have "new terms of reference" so that it can "consider distorted and inaccurate coverage of groups and communities as well of individuals". Tougher rules and prohibitions on reporting will, they claim, produce more "community sensitive reporting about multi-culturalism and British Muslim identities" which will "increase… a sense of common ground, shared belonging and civic responsibility".

Their advocacy of prohibitions suggests the aim of the "experts" is to put political Islam beyond the scope of media inquiry. For the result of those prohibitions would certainly be to introduce a new level of censorship into the coverage of Muslim affairs - and that would be quite wrong. While condemning violence here, the MCB has sent out mixed signals over political violence abroad and over integration.The press has a responsibility to highlight and explore these. That's part of its role in helping people make sensible, informed decisions at election-time - something which most of us, including the vast majority of British Muslims, regard as essential. By discouraging the media from performing that role, Ken and his "experts" won't help British Muslims or the cause of integration: they could seriously damage it.

John Ware is a reporter for BBC Current Affairs

Thursday, 15 November 2007

London Evening Standard: "How Ken whitewashed the Muslim extremists"

Another article about "The Search for Common Ground" report for the GLA. Interestingly, a lot of the report was cut before publication much of which - in my opinion - was highly dubious anyway and didn't deserve to make the final cut. Even some of that which has made the final report is also questionable.

There has been too much 'politic-ing' going on in the background and it's a shame - as this article suggests - that the credibility of the sound research that underpins some of the chapters (mine included) is being overshadowed by the associations being made to certain certain groups and/or individuals.

Sadly, I have no option but to agree with some of the comments made in this article...



Watching Ken Livingstone at the mayoral press conference yesterday was like watching an old bare-knuckle fighter. Horrible, but you had to admire his nerve.

He spun away from danger so adroitly you could blink and miss the trickiness of the foot movements. He landed low blows and then turned to the referee as if butter wouldn't melt in his mouth.

Ostensibly he was releasing a report by "leading academics and experts on Islam" on Islamophobia. He had a poll which showed that Muslim Londoners weren't very different from other Londoners, which was fair enough, and descriptions of the prejudices Muslim journalists face. These revelations were merely the build-up to the shocking news that "leading academics and experts" had found that 91 per cent of articles on Islam "were negative in their associations".

Ninety-one per cent! Imagine. I knew there was bigotry, but not the "torrent of Islamophobic demonisation" Livingstone described. Where could we get further particulars?

We couldn't, initially. Although Livingstone had sat on the report for weeks, no copies were available before the conference - "problems with couriers", apparently. It arrived while Livingstone was speaking and as we skim-read we learned that it was giving Islam "negative associations" to report that the Iranian regime was holding a conference of Holocaust deniers. Muslim democrats in Iran opposed it. Livingstone and his " leading academics" could not. Meanwhile, journalists - including me - conveyed "negative associations" when we wrote that Jack Straw was standing up for the rights of women when he criticised the full veil. Muslim feminists oppose the veil. Mr Livingstone and his "leading academics and experts" cannot.

The worst of it was that a large chunk of the report was a devious attack on a Panorama expose; of the Muslim Council of Britain by John Ware of the BBC. As luck would have it, Ware was at the press conference and able to point out that all the criticisms of the MCB that he broadcast came from liberal-minded British Muslims. Were they, like Iranian democrats and Arab feminists, Islamophobes as well?

Then he looked at the press release and noticed that one of Livingstone's nine "leading academics and experts" wasn't an academic or expert at all but Inayat Bungawala of the MCB. Later I discovered that two others were also from the MCB. At a cost of £30,000 to the taxpayer, Livingstone was allowing the MCB and its friends to rubbish a well-sourced and balanced documentary and dressing up the results as an impartial study.

I've written a book on why the Left is going along with the Islamist Right and won't go over it all again here. The point is that while the Labour government has cut links with the MCB, and announced that no organisation will receive public money until it explicitly opposes extremism, Livingstone can't admit a mistake. He never explains, never apologises and always attacks.

Wednesday, 14 November 2007

Guardian Media: Study shows 'demonisation' of Muslims

Here is a piece that appeared in the Guardian Media today about the GLA report. If you want to view the article in its original form, click here.


A "torrent" of negative stories has been revealed by a study of the portrayal of Muslims and Islam in the media, according to a report published yesterday.

Research into one week's news coverage showed that 91% of articles in national newspapers about Muslims were negative. The London mayor, Ken Livingstone, who commissioned the study, said the findings were a "damning indictment" of the media and urged editors and programme makers to review the way they portray Muslims.

"The overall picture presented by the media is that Islam is profoundly different from and a threat to the west," he said. "There is a scale of imbalance which no fair-minded person would think is right." Only 4% of the 352 articles studied were positive, he said.

Livingstone said the findings showed a "hostile and scaremongering attitude" towards Islam and likened the coverage to the way the left was attacked by national newspapers in the early 1980s. "The charge is that there are virtually no positive or balanced images of Islam being portrayed," he said. "I think there is a demonisation of Islam going on which damages community relations and creates alarm among Muslims."

Among examples in the study was a report which claimed that Christmas was being banned in one area because it offended Muslims, which researchers said was "inaccurate and alarmist". The report said that Muslims in Britain were sometimes depicted as a threat to traditional British values, and the coverage weakened government attempts to reduce extremism. The report is an amalgam of research projects individually prepared by members of a panel. Some research, examining published newspaper articles and reporting the experiences of Muslim journalists, involved Hugh Muir, of the Guardian.

The Search for Common Ground

You can download the Greater London Authority (GLA) report, 'The Search for Common Ground" can now be downloaded by clicking here.

My research and writing can be found in chapter 2 of the report. I want to make sure that everyone is aware of my contribution as there have been 'political' problems with some parts of the report. The key findings of my chapter are shown below (reproduced from the Executive Summary):

Chapter 2: A normal week?

To explore the context and implications of representations of Islam and Muslims in the media, a study was made of the British press over the course of a week. The week beginning Monday 8 May 2006 was chosen at random about a month in advance. A count was made of every article mentioning ‘Islam’, ‘Muslims’, derivatives such as ‘Islamic’ and ‘Islamist’, and words and phrases with an obvious association with Islam, for example ‘Sunni’ and ‘Shi’a’.

On the basis of these criteria, 352 articles were identified. They were categorised according to type of paper, whether they were about domestic or international affairs, whether the context was negative, positive or neutral, and whether the articles expressed a sense of threat or crisis. The principal findings included:

• There were substantial differences between daily newspapers with regard to how many articles mentioning Islam or Muslims they contained during the week in question. There were just over 50 articles in the Guardian, over 40 in The Times, Financial Times, Daily Telegraph and Independent, but less than 20 in the Sun, Mirror, Express and Star.

• Tabloids and broadsheets differed not only in the amount of coverage they provided but also in whether they focused on domestic or international affairs. Close to 60 per cent of articles in tabloids pertained to Britain and 40 per cent to the wider world. In the case of the broadsheets, however, the proportions were the other way round: 60 per cent were about the wider world, and 40 per cent about Britain.

• Of the 352 articles that referred to Islam and Muslims during the week in question, 91 per cent were judged to be negative in their associations. Only four per cent were judged to be positive, and five per cent were judged neutral.

• In 12 of the 19 papers studied during the week there were no positive associations.

• In the tabloids, 96 per cent of all articles were judged to be negative, compared with 89 per cent in the broadsheets. It is relevant to bear in mind in this connection that the combined circulation of the The search for common ground Muslims, non-Muslims and the UK media xvii tabloids is about three times greater than that of the broadsheets (May 2007 figures).

• It was judged that almost half of the articles represented Islam as a threat. Of these, about a third pertained to Britain and two-thirds to the wider world.

• The overall picture presented in the media during the week in question was that on the world stage Islam is profoundly different from, and a serious threat to, the West; and that, within Britain, Muslims are different from – and a threat to – ‘us’.

24 Hour Dash.com: Media report reveals 'torrent' of negative Muslim

Another article about the GLA research. Click link in widget to view 'au naturel'...

A "torrent" of negative stories has been revealed by a study of the portrayal of Muslims and Islam in the British media, according to a report today.

Research into one week's news coverage showed that 91% of articles in national newspapers about Muslims were negative.

London mayor Ken Livingstone, who commissioned the study, said the findings were a "damning indictment" on the media and he urged editors and programme makers to review the way they portray Muslims.

"The overall picture presented by the media is that Islam is profoundly different from and a threat to the West," he said.

"There is a scale of imbalance which no fair-minded person would think is right."

Only 4% of the 352 articles studied last year were positive, he said.

Mr Livingstone told his weekly news conference that the findings showed a "hostile and scaremongering attitude" among the national media towards Islam and likened the coverage to the way the Left was attacked by national newspapers in the early 1980s.

"The charge is that there are virtually no positive or balanced images of Islam being portrayed," he said.

"I think there is a demonisation of Islam going on which damages community relations and creates alarm among Muslims."

Among the examples highlighted in the study was a report which claimed that Christmas was being banned in one area because it offended Muslims, which researchers said was "inaccurate and alarmist".

The report said that Muslims in Britain were depicted as a threat to traditional British values.

Alternative world views or opinions were not mentioned and facts were frequently distorted, exaggerated or over-simplified, said the report.

The researchers said that the coverage weakened government attempts to reduce and prevent extremism.

A separate opinion poll published by Mr Livingstone today showed that Muslims in London were more likely to feel "British" in their attitudes than other members of the community.

More Muslims were proud of their local area compared with other members of the public.

Associated Press of Pakistan: "Publication of a major study into portrayal of Muslims"

As before, this is another article about the work I was commissioned to undertake for the Greater London Authority. You cannot use the widget to the right to open the article in a new window so you will have to click on the following link:


LONDON, Nov 13 (APP): The Mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, on Tuesday welcomed the publication of a major study into the portrayal of Muslims and Islam in the UK print and broadcast media.

The report, ‘The Search for Common Ground,’ was researched by 9 leading academics, professionals from the media industry and experts on Islam, and shows that during the period of investigation the national media overwhelming portrayed Muslims and Islam in a negative way.

Speaking on the occasion ,The Mayor said:

‘While there were some examples of good practice, one of the most startling findings of this report is that in one typical week in 2006, over 90% of the articles that referred to Islam and Muslims were negative. The overall picture presented by the media is that Islam is profoundly different from and a threat to the west.

‘I hope that those who make the day - to - day decisions in the newsrooms of our national papers and TV will read this report and take on board the researchers recommendations.

Among the key findings of the report are that in one week, 8th to the 14th May 2006 there were 352 articles that mentioned Islam, Muslim, Islamic or Islamist, in the national daily press and of those 91% were deemed by the professional researcher team to have been negative.

In 12 out of 19 papers covered, the researchers concluded that every article carried was negative. 96% of Tabloid coverage was assessed to be negative while 89% of broadsheet reporting was deemed to be negative.

They also found that Muslims in the national press were portrayed as being a threat to traditional British customs, that there was little or no common ground between the West and Islam and that the tone of language in many articles was emotive, immoderate, alarmist or abusive.

Robin Richardson was the leader of the team that produced the report and is Co-Director of the Insted Consultancy, the company that undertook the research project said:

‘This is one of the first major pieces of research to be conducted into the manner and style of the way the UK media portrays one of the UK’s most significant religious and cultural groups. Our clear conclusion after twelve months of research and taking evidence is that the coverage we saw over this period was likely to provoke and increase feelings of insecurity, suspicion and anxiety amongst many non Muslims while at the same time causing many Muslims to feel vulnerable and alienated.

Out of London’s eight million population, there are over 600,000 Muslims living in the British capital. The report was researched between the 1st May 20006 and 30th April 2007.